Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Talking About Teaching

What follows are a few thoughts triggered by the difficulty I've been having with drafting a statement of teaching philosophy. Why is it, I wonder, that so many educators are better at doing the pragmatic work of teaching than they are at articulating the philosophy behind their teaching? Is the gulf between our practice and our theory something to worry about? I want to suggest that this gulf derives at least in part from the fact that our teaching goals are so often multiple, inconsistent, even incongruous. . . .

• On the one hand, good teachers want to provide students with the knowledge and skills that will eventually enable them to become equal partners in disciplinary conversations. On the other hand, we want to model forms of democratic discussion premised on the presumption of equality in the present.

• On the one hand, good teachers often reward students who exhibit the cool-headed composure characteristic of rational thinkers. On the other hand, we encourage students to cultivate the passionate attachments that motivate innovative thinking and persuasive argumentation.

• On the one hand, good teachers want to help students learn to think critically about literature, cultural materials, and the problems facing our world today. On the other hand, we want to expose our students to cultural materials that they can feel good about: materials that provide models of a better world, and that function as mooring posts for their optimism, curiosity, and generosity.

That list could go on for ever. But those brief examples should suffice to establish that the best teachers make use of eclectic methods to accomplish goals which are not only multiple but often contradictory. And it's a good thing, too!

No comments: